Elden Ring DLC Boss Tier List: All Remembrance Bosses Ranked in Shadow of the Erdtree
With the release of Elden Ring's highly anticipated DLC, Shadow of the Erdtree, players have been treated to a fresh set of bosses that challenge their skills, patience, and understanding of the game’s mechanics. This DLC introduces 34 unique-ish bosses, excluding reskinned versions from the base game unless they’ve received significant changes, making the ranking process a bit of a tightrope walk. Boss difficulty can vary significantly based on your build, blessing level, and the Elden Ring Runes strategies you employ, so the following tier list represents a comprehensive view of the bosses, ranked from hardest to easiest.

1. Bayle The Dread – The Ultimate Dragon Challenge
Bayle The Dread stands at the pinnacle of this tier list, thanks to his overwhelming power and the intricacies of his fight. Bayle is a dragon boss, and like most dragons in Elden Ring, his large health pool, powerful attacks, and aggressive nature make him an intimidating opponent. What makes Bayle stand out is his armored body, which minimizes the damage players deal unless they can land precise hits on his head, his weak point. This becomes particularly challenging in the second phase when Bayle transforms into a more powerful, Super Saiyan-like version, sprouting new wings and summoning meteors. The delayed explosion from his laser move is another nightmare for players, requiring perfect timing to dodge. For those who struggle, Egon, the NPC summon, is essential, but even with assistance, this fight is a brutal test of skill. Anti-dragon weapons like the Dragon Katana can be effective, but not all builds can support these tools, further complicating the encounter.

2. Messmer the Impaler – A Serpent-Man of Deceptive Combos
Messmer the Impaler delivers a fight that tests both your reaction time and your ability to read patterns. This boss starts with a deceptively standard set of attacks but quickly escalates into something more dangerous. His combos often include extra thrusts or slashes that catch players off guard. In his second phase, Messmer transforms into a serpent-man, gaining new attacks and further increasing the fight’s complexity. The telegraphs for his attacks are well-executed, but the fight remains punishing, especially if you fail to anticipate his moves. Messmer requires a mix of patience and precise dodging, making him a formidable opponent that comes close to Bayle’s level of challenge.

3. Midra, Lord of Frenzied Flame – A Fiery Deception
Midra’s fight begins in a seemingly straightforward manner, with the boss appearing to be a mere man who can be bullied into submission. However, this is only the calm before the storm. In his second phase, Midra reveals himself as a fire orb-headed monster that causes massive damage and can inflict Madness on the player. While Madness resist gear is helpful, it is not required for victory. The fight is engaging, and the boss’s attack telegraphs allow for counterattacks, creating a natural flow to the encounter. Midra stands out for offering a challenge without the overwhelming complexity found in other bosses, but the Madness status effect adds enough of a layer to make it a tough fight nonetheless.

4. Rellana, Twin Moon Knight – The Relentless Onslaught
Rellana is a relentless boss who continually bombards players with attack after attack. Her nine-hit combo is overwhelming, and her triple-hit move can be devastating if not anticipated properly. Rellana’s arm movements, which act independently of her body, can be confusing and hard to track. She also utilizes homing soul mass, forcing players into a defensive stance at times, which pauses the fight and makes dodging a nightmare. The second phase introduces even deadlier combos and more challenging magic attacks. Rellana’s combination of speed, variety, and offensive power makes her one of the most exhausting and demanding fights in Shadow of the Erdtree.

5. Metry, Mother of Fingers – The Challenge of the Cathedral
Metry presents an interesting fight that begins with a fairly manageable attack set. The real challenge is navigating through her finger legs, which can crush players if not careful. The fight is locked behind a cathedral quest, which adds an extra layer of difficulty just to reach her. Her mechanics aren’t incredibly difficult, but the difficulty spike comes from her mobility and the need to stay constantly on the move. She’s an example of how environmental factors, combined with solid boss mechanics, can make a seemingly manageable boss into a formidable challenge.

6. Demi-Human Swordmaster Onze – The Erratic Threat
The Demi-Human Swordmaster Onze fight is an interesting one, as the boss’s erratic jumping and unpredictable movements make it difficult to find any patterns to exploit. His magic sword adds an additional layer of difficulty, causing frost buildup, which can freeze players and disrupt dodging. While it’s possible to defeat him on the second try, his erratic nature keeps players on edge throughout the fight, turning what might seem like an easy battle into a nerve-wracking encounter.

7. Death Knight – The Self-Healing Menace
Death Knights are known for their ability to heal by grabbing the player, making them especially annoying. The challenge of the fight lies in counteracting their healing abilities. Players can equip a charm that restores HP on critical hits, which helps mitigate the healing, but these knights remain formidable opponents. The fact that they can regain full health with one grab makes it important to approach them with care and patience. While manageable, their healing mechanic creates an artificial difficulty that requires careful strategy to overcome.

8. Divine Beast Dancing Lion – The Synchronized Duel
The Divine Beast Dancing Lion is a visually unique boss, essentially two figures in a lion costume, working together with perfect synchronization. The fight is challenging due to the unpredictability of their movements and their ability to switch between lightning, frost, and wind attacks. Lightning can interrupt rolls, frost brings shockwaves and frost buildup, and wind is the easiest to handle. The sheer variety of elements at play, combined with the boss’s fast-moving attack patterns, makes this an engaging yet difficult fight.

9. Scadutree Avatar – The Surprisingly Manageable Three-Phase Fight
While most multi-phase bosses get increasingly difficult as they progress, the Scadutree Avatar is a surprisingly manageable opponent. Despite having three phases, the fight is straightforward, with the avatar’s sunflower face being the main weak point. It has a few bleed thorn attacks that require careful rolling, but the avatar’s infrequent attacks make it a relatively easy fight. The lack of significant changes in attack patterns across phases makes this one of the more predictable and straightforward battles in the DLC.

10. Romina, Saint of the Bud – A Classic Dark Souls Encounter
Romina, Saint of the Bud, brings to mind classic Dark Souls bosses, such as Quelaag or Scorpioness Najka. Her fight is defined by the threat of Scarlet Rot, which adds a status effect that players must manage carefully. The attack patterns are not too complicated, but the status effects she inflicts on the player require constant vigilance. While not the most difficult encounter in Shadow of the Erdtree, Romina’s fight offers a good balance of challenge and accessibility, especially for players familiar with similar status-inflicting fights from the base game.

Conclusion
The Shadow of the Erdtree DLC in Elden Ring introduces a set of bosses that range from impossibly hard to surprisingly manageable, with each fight offering unique challenges. While Bayle the Dread takes the top spot for its overwhelming power and complex mechanics, Messmer the Impaler and Rellana follow closely behind with their deceptive combos and relentless onslaughts. Bosses like Midra, Lord of Frenzied Flame and Metry, Mother of Fingers provide a more methodical challenge, relying on timing and strategy rather than sheer force.

On the easier end, bosses like Lamenter and Demi-Human Queen Marigga offer a more relaxed encounter, but they should not be underestimated by newer players who may still be learning the ropes of the DLC’s mechanics.

Ultimately, the tier list reflects a broad spectrum of difficulty, where the boss fights are designed to test every aspect of a player’s combat ability, from reaction time to strategic thinking. Whether you are a seasoned veteran or a newcomer to the world of Elden Ring, Shadow of the Erdtree offers a rich, varied experience that will continue to challenge players long after they’ve completed the Elden Ring Items for sale main campaign.